The Observer, the Eye and the Meaning of "I"

Deogratius Wilfred Kadete
0
Advertisement
The Observer, the Eye and the Meaning of "I"

The Observer, the Eye and the Meaning of "I"

The Observer, the Eye and the Meaning of I

We are already human before we say "I". So why do we need the word at all?

The word human names what we are. The word I names where we stand. One is a category; the other is a position. When we say "I", we are not repeating our species. We are pointing to the one who is speaking, seeing and experiencing at this very moment.

This essay imagines a bridge between linguistics, child development, neuroscience and the philosophy of consciousness. The idea is simple: the first-person self is not only a word in grammar. It is the place from which each of us meets reality.

But we must walk carefully. What the evidence shows and what imagination proposes are two different things, and both deserve to be honest.

Human and I

A name tells us what something is. A pronoun tells us who is speaking.

When a child is born, the child is already human. Nobody needs to teach the child that. But the child must still learn to say "I", and that learning does not happen alone.

Learning to Say I

We do not invent the word "I". We receive it.

Research suggests that children acquire personal pronouns through social interaction, through hearing language around them, and through a growing understanding of other people.

  • Oshima-Takane, Takane and Shultz (1999) used computer network models and analysis to suggest how important overheard speech and conversations with many speakers are. A child must discover something strange: the same words, "me" and "you", point to different people depending on who is talking.
  • Imbens-Bailey and Pan (1998) studied children at 14, 20 and 32 months and looked at how they refer to themselves and others when talking with their parents.
  • Smolík and Bláhová (2021) worked with 58 Czech-speaking children aged 30 months and found that first- and second-person reference develops together with general language and social understanding.
  • Lewis and Ramsay (2004) followed 66 children at 15, 18 and 21 months and found that those who recognised themselves in a mirror used more personal pronouns, such as "me" and "mine", and showed more advanced pretend play.

From these studies, one lesson stands out:

We learn to name ourselves by meeting other people.

When we listen, we collect the word. When we imitate, we try the word. When we understand, we own the word. The "I" we use every day was first spoken to us by others.

The Eye of the Observer

Here is the heart of the imagination. Perhaps the true answer behind "I" is not the grammatical word, but the eye: the observer who experiences reality.

Neuroscience offers an interesting door. Baars, Ramsøy and Laureys (2003), in Brain, Conscious Experience and the Observing Self, discuss how conscious perception involves more than recognising objects in the world. Their review looks at brain systems that support a first-person perspective and bring conscious experiences together.

In simple words: seeing a tree and experiencing ourselves as the one who sees the tree are two different aspects of consciousness.

Not every thinker agrees. Thomas Clark (2004) replied that conscious experience does not need a separate observing self; the self may simply be modelled within experience. The question is still open, and that is what makes it worth imagining.

Let us separate the ideas clearly:

ConceptWhat it does
HumanBiological identity
IThe speaker referring to oneself
MeThe self in the object position
EyeThe biological organ of sight
ObserverThe one who experiences or attends
Self-awarenessThe ability to become aware of oneself

The last three — eye, observer and self-awareness — are where this imagination lives.

Watching Eyes

We do not only look. We are also looked at.

Conty, George and Hietanen (2016), in Watching Eyes Effects: When Others Meet the Self, review how direct eye contact affects self-referential processing, attention, memory and social behaviour. They propose that being looked at can switch on the processes through which we judge information in relation to ourselves.

This is beautiful to imagine. When another person's eyes meet ours, we become more aware of ourselves. The observer is never truly alone. The one who sees is shaped by being seen.

Adam and the Name

Why did Adam need a name when he was already MAN?

In Genesis, Adam is connected with adamah, the ground or soil. The story ties human identity to the earth from which humanity is described as coming.

But notice the difference:

  • Humanity names a general category.
  • Adam names a particular person.
  • A name gives us a way to call, distinguish and remember that one individual.

We should be careful here too. The link between Adam and adamah is a literary wordplay. It should not automatically be taken as proof of historical word origin. Wordplay and etymology answer different questions.

Still, the philosophical question remains: why does an individual need a separate name when the individual already belongs to a known category?

Because classifying and identifying solve different problems. To know what something is does not tell us which one it is. And naming something does not necessarily explain what that thing truly is.

The Observer Observed

Mograbi, Hall, Arantes and Huntley (2024) describe self-awareness as a multidimensional phenomenon built from different cognitive processes. One important part is the ability to take oneself as an object of awareness.

This opens a door to a deep question: if I am the observer, can I also become the observed?

Imagine it step by step:

  1. I observe a tree.
  2. I become aware that I am observing the tree.
  3. I begin to examine the person who is observing the tree.
  4. I recognise that the observer has now become the observed.

This is self-reference. It does not mean there is a second little observer hiding inside us. It shows that awareness can turn back and look at its own seeing.

I and Eye: A Note on Words

If we want this imagination to stand strong, we must be honest about language.

In English, I and eye sound the same, but they have different meanings and different histories.

  • I comes from Old English ic, the first-person pronoun.
  • Eye comes from Old English ēage, the organ of sight.

So there is no established evidence that the word "I" grew out of the word "eye".

But the idea does not need that history to live. It can stand as a philosophical interpretation: a way of seeing the relationship between first-person identity and visual perspective. And that is a stronger place to stand.

Three Questions

The human being is not the same as the word used to name the human being.

The word I represents the speaker. The eye is one of the ways the individual meets the outside world. The observer is the inner position from which experience is organised. The words we use for ourselves do not fully explain our existence.

We can explore this through three questions:

  1. Ontological: What is the self?
  2. Epistemological: How does the self know that it exists?
  3. Linguistic: How does the self represent itself through language?

These questions are related, but answering one does not answer the others.

What Stands and What Is Imagined

IdeaWhere it stands
Children acquire first-person reference through social and language interaction.Supported by developmental research.
Conscious experience involves a first-person perspective.Supported by consciousness research.
The eye represents the observer behind the word "I".A philosophical interpretation that needs further argument.

The third idea is not a scientific discovery. Its value lies in the relationship it invites us to imagine.

The Question That Remains

A child learns to say "I" by listening to others. Later, the child uses "I" to stand apart from those same others.

So when does the borrowed word become a lived self? At what moment does the "I" we heard become the "I" we are?

That is where the philosophy of words ends and the mystery of consciousness begins.

We learned the word from others. We found the self within.

References

  1. Baars, B. J., Ramsøy, T. Z., & Laureys, S. (2003). Brain, conscious experience and the observing self. Trends in Neurosciences, 26(12), 671–675. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tins.2003.09.015
  2. Clark, T. W. (2004, February 1). Is there an observing self? Response to Baars et al. Science and Consciousness Review. https://mbscience.org/?p=235
  3. Conty, L., George, N., & Hietanen, J. K. (2016). Watching Eyes effects: When others meet the self. Consciousness and Cognition, 45, 184–197. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.concog.2016.08.016
  4. Imbens-Bailey, A., & Pan, B. A. (1998). Pragmatics of self- and other-reference in young children. Social Development, 7(2), 219–233. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9507.00063
  5. Lewis, M., & Ramsay, D. (2004). Development of self-recognition, personal pronoun use, and pretend play during the 2nd year. Child Development, 75(6), 1821–1831. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8624.2004.00819.x
  6. Mograbi, D. C., Hall, S., Arantes, B., & Huntley, J. (2024). The cognitive neuroscience of self-awareness: Current framework, clinical implications, and future research directions. WIREs Cognitive Science, 15(2), e1670. https://doi.org/10.1002/wcs.1670
  7. Oshima-Takane, Y., Takane, Y., & Shultz, T. R. (1999). The learning of first and second person pronouns in English: Network models and analysis. Journal of Child Language, 26(3), 545–575. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305000999003906
  8. Smolík, F., & Bláhová, V. (2021). Early linguistic reference to first and second person depends on social understanding as well as language skills: Evidence from Czech 30-month-olds. First Language, 41(1), 109–125. https://doi.org/10.1177/0142723720938898
g1FOQWf5WECoi-IzluCFR3zydM0_OwHBBqTEPUq5ybCqv106LQNhC73_7iuZv5jp2LkZ9OFjj8H0_yTQyvf6JPGSwmh22X0LEWvR-p-U1pLR20eg-Zpoozkx3EfMJqpQW8QJjRpx9GZyFJ3do/s320/140879.jpg"/>
Advertisement
  • Newer

    You’re reading the newest post

Post a Comment

0 Comments

Thank you for reading!

Post a Comment (0)
3/related/default